Cabot Creamery Butter Recall 2025 – What You Need to Know About the Recalled Butter

If you’ve recently picked up a stick of Cabot butter, it's time to check your fridge. One of America’s most trusted dairy brands, Cabot Creamery, has issued a voluntary recall of its Extra Creamy Premium Sea Salted Butter in 2025.

This recall is catching national attention—and for good reason. It’s not just about taste or texture. It’s about safety.

Let’s break down everything you need to know about the Cabot Creamery Butter Recall 2025, including the reason, the risks, the affected states, and what you should do next.

Why was the butter recalled

The butter was pulled from shelves due to elevated levels of coliform bacteria. That might sound technical, but here’s the plain truth:

Coliform bacteria can signal unsanitary conditions and potential fecal contamination.

That’s a serious red flag in food production. While there’s no confirmed illness at this point, coliform presence raises health concerns, especially for people with weakened immune systems.

Cabot Creamery discovered the issue through routine quality testing—and acted fast to issue a recall.

Cabot Creamery butter recall affects one specific product

This Cabot Creamery butter recall only applies to one specific item. Here are the details:

• Product: Extra Creamy Premium Sea Salted Butter

• Size: 8-ounce package

• Lot Code: 090925-055

• Best By Date: September 9, 2025

If your butter matches this description, it’s time to stop using it.

Look for the lot code printed near the expiration date on the packaging. That’s your best clue to confirm whether your butter is part of the recall.

Where was the butter recalled and sold

The butter recalled under this warning was distributed in seven U.S. states:

• Vermont

• New Hampshire

• Maine

• Connecticut

• New York

• Pennsylvania

• Arkansas

According to Cabot Creamery, most of the affected butter was pulled before reaching shelves. However, 17 packages were confirmed sold in Vermont stores.

If you're in any of these states, now’s the time to check your fridge.

Health risks linked to the Cabot Creamery butter recall

The FDA classified this as a Class III recall—meaning it’s not likely to cause serious health effects. Still, the butter recalled could contain coliform bacteria, which are typically linked to contaminated water or fecal matter.

It’s especially risky for children, the elderly, or people with weak immune systems.

Even if you don’t get sick from it, consuming food with high coliform levels is never a good idea.

What to do if you have the recalled butter

If you’ve purchased the butter recalled by Cabot Creamery, here’s what to do:

1. Do not consume it.

2. Throw it away in a sealed container.

3. Or return it to the store for a refund.

4. Contact Cabot Creamery with questions:

   • Phone: 1-888-792-2268 (Monday–Friday, 9:30 AM–5:00 PM EST)

   • Email: info@cabotcreamery.com

You don’t need to provide a receipt in most cases, but check with the store first.

No illnesses reported so far

As of now, no illnesses have been linked to this Cabot Creamery butter recall.

That’s reassuring. But the company isn’t taking any chances. Cabot and its parent company, Agri-Mark, acted quickly to issue the recall once internal testing showed abnormal bacterial levels.

Why the butter recall matters to consumers

This butter recalled story isn’t just about one product. It’s a reminder of how food safety processes work behind the scenes.

Cabot Creamery has a solid reputation. Their fast response shows responsibility and transparency—two qualities every food brand should have.

This recall also highlights the importance of checking lot codes, even for everyday items like butter.

Final thoughts on the Cabot Creamery Butter Recall 2025

Here’s your quick summary:

• Product: Cabot Extra Creamy Sea Salted Butter (8 oz)

• Issue: Elevated coliform bacteria levels

• Lot Code: 090925-055

• Best By: September 9, 2025

• States affected: VT, NH, ME, CT, NY, PA, AR

• Action: Discard or return for a refund

The Cabot Creamery Butter Recall 2025 may only impact a small batch, but it’s a reminder that food safety starts with awareness.

Check your fridge. Share this article. And when in doubt, always play it safe.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not replace official recall notices from the FDA or Cabot Creamery.